Eye Color Blog Image

Eye Color, Natural Haircolor Category, and Lift: Finding Common Ground

November 20, 2026•8 min read

Many colorists consider a guest's eyes and natural haircolor category before they formulate. In their experience, these cues help them anticipate how the hair will lift and how much warmth will appear. Others have asked whether these cues have a scientific basis, and that is a fair question.

Both views come from the same place: a commitment to predictable, beautiful results for our guests. This blog post looks for common ground. It separates the principles that educators, chemists and manufacturers already share from the observations that come from experience behind the chair, and it looks at what eye cues have delivered in real salons.

What we all agree on

Educators, chemists and manufacturers already share a common foundation, and every forecast should start there.

  • Natural color comes from two melanins. Black-brown eumelanin and red-yellow pheomelanin create the range of natural shades. Ito and Wakamatsu (2011) showed that hair color mostly reflects the amount and ratio of the two.

  • Lightening exposes underlying pigment in a predictable order. Formulating means determining the underlying pigment at the target level, so lifting from level 4 to level 6 means working with orange. Levels 3 to 6 carry stronger underlying pigment than levels 7 to 10 (Hair Colour for Hairstylists: Level 2).

  • Manufacturers teach the same thing. Wella's color chart guide uses a Lightening Curve to show how tone shifts as hair lightens, so the colorist can work with, neutralize or enhance it.

  • The two pigments break down at different rates. Researchers at Clairol, Wolfram and Albrecht (1987), found that pheomelanin resists peroxide and light better than eumelanin.

  • Permanent color builds on what remains. Peroxide lightens the natural color, then new dye molecules form inside the hair and stay trapped there (Royal Society of Chemistry). The natural pigment left behind is part of every result.

  • Consultation and strand testing come first. A good consultation covers level, Natural Haircolor Category, tone, percentage of gray, the target, and the underlying pigment at that target (Level 2 text). A strand test confirms the plan when lifting artificial color or when porosity is extreme, uneven or resistant.

Natural haircolor category: what each guest is born with

Natural haircolor category is the category each person is born into and keeps for life, and it tells more of the story than today's level. Level describes how light or dark the hair is now. Category reflects the pigment makeup a person inherits, which can shape how hair responds even when two guests share the same level.

  • Same level, different response. Wolfram and Albrecht (1987) matched untreated brown and red hair for starting lightness. Under peroxide, the brown hair's eumelanin broke down more readily, while the red hair's pheomelanin held up.

  • Set by genes. Ito and Wakamatsu (2011) found that MC1R genotype predicts the ratio of dark to warm pigment in hair.

  • Lasting through life. In Kukla-Bartoszek et al. (2018), most children whose blond hair darkened to brown were still predicted blond from their DNA. Their genes pointed to the category they started with, even as their level changed.

These findings fit what many colorists see behind the chair: two guests at the same level can lift very differently.

Eye observations: grounded in biology, still being measured

Eye cues rest on real pigment biology, but no published study has yet tested them against lightening results.

  • Eyes and hair share genes. Sulem et al. (2007) studied 2,986 Icelanders and about 3,900 more people in follow-up, and found a variant in SLC24A4 linked to both eye and hair color. Branicki et al. (2009) found that the main blue-eye variant, in HERC2, is also tied to hair color and interacts with MC1R.

  • Pigment type shows in the iris. Prota et al. (1998) linked green irises to pheomelanin and found that eye color depends on both the amount and the type of melanin. Peles et al. (2009) measured a eumelanin to pheomelanin ratio of 14.8 in dark brown irises versus 1.3 in blue-green ones.

  • The limbal ring is partly optical. In Shyu and Wyatt (2009), the ring's prominence fell by about 55% on average when saline goggles neutralized the cornea's optics. Peshek et al. (2011) found the ring becomes less prominent with age, so it may be a less steady cue in mature clients.

  • What is still open. No published study has compared eye color, flecks or the limbal ring with lightening outcomes. For now, the clearest picture comes from salon experience, covered below.

A starting point, not a rule

Used well, natural haircolor category and eye cues give the colorist a starting forecast, and the strand test confirms it.

  • Lead with the hair. Level, tone, percentage of gray, color history and the underlying pigment at the target still set the formula.

  • Add the category. Note the client's natural haircolor category alongside today's level, since the two can tell different stories.

  • Use eye cues to adjust expectations. Darker irises, warm flecks or a heavy limbal ring can prompt a plan for more warmth or a slower lift.

  • Confirm before committing. A strand test turns the forecast into a result you can see.

  • Speak in tendencies. "Often" and "in my experience" are accurate and respectful; "always" and "never" overstate what anyone has measured.

The aim is a forecast accurate enough to guide the formula, shared with the guest as an expectation rather than a promise.

Results behind the chair

The strongest case for eye cues comes from the salon, where colorists have long used them to anticipate lift and warmth. Colorists who read the eyes before they formulate describe practical benefits:

  • Fewer surprises with warmth. Expecting extra warmth lets the colorist plan the toner in advance. Combed Education advises a green-based toner for green-eyed clients, who often lift warm.

  • Safer lifting decisions. Martin Rodriguez uses eye color to guide developer choice, safe lifting limits and pre-toning.

  • More consistent blondes. He notes that ignoring eye color can lead to excess warmth, over-processing and inconsistent blondes.

  • Clearer expectations for the guest. Combed Education notes that amber-eyed guests tend to lift warm and turn brassy again as color fades, which is worth discussing before the service.

These are outcomes colorists see in practice, and they line up with the pigment science above. Each forecast is still confirmed with a strand test, so the guest's result stays safe and predictable.

Eye color has a long legacy in the haircolorist's consultation. Contributors with real salon experience using it as a tool include:

  • Mags Kavanaugh owned three salons and served as a National Artistic Educator for Clairol and Matrix. She founded AskMags.com, a mentoring site for cosmetologists.

  • Thia Spearing is credited with the 1 to 5 grades of porosity that colorists use. Her definition appears in the Board of Certified Haircolorists ColorCraft, and she regularly teaches color harmony internationally.

  • Tom Dispenza founded Chromastics Hair Color, a company offering haircolor products and education, after rising to Worldwide Senior Manager of Education at Clairol. He is president of the Worldwide HairColorists Association. He has long stressed eye color, skin tone, hair texture and ethnic origin in formulation, which his book Becoming a Master Colorist covers.

  • David Velasco brings about 40 years in hairdressing, including ten years as Wella's National Artistic Director and time as Director of Haircolor at Bumble and Bumble. He has self-published eight books on haircolor.

Experience shared openly, colorist to colorist, is how our craft has always advanced. That same spirit shaped ColorCraft: Advanced Haircolor Strategies, the official textbook of the Board of Certified Haircolorists. It brings together the knowledge of more than 100 contributors.

Used alongside the fundamentals we all agree on, eye cues give colorists one more way to start every service with a clearer picture.

Sources

  • AbeBooks. David Velasco author page. abebooks.co.uk

  • Board of Certified Haircolorists. ColorCraft: Advanced Haircolor Strategies, certification programs page. boardofcertifiedhaircolorists.com

  • Branicki W, et al. Interactions between HERC2, OCA2 and MC1R may influence human pigmentation phenotype. Annals of Human Genetics. 2009. doi:10.1111/j.1469-1809.2009.00504.x. Abstract as quoted by Discover

  • Combed Education. How to use eye color to predict lift. Blog post

  • Dispenza T. Tom Dispenza, Master Colorist. tomdispenza.com

  • Emsley J. Hair dyes. Royal Society of Chemistry education site. edu.rsc.org

  • Hair Colour for Hairstylists: Level 2. Open textbook, sections 2.3 (Colour Assessment) and 3 (Product Selection and Formulation). Colour assessment and formulation

  • Ito S, Wakamatsu K. Diversity of human hair pigmentation as studied by chemical analysis of eumelanin and pheomelanin. Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology. 2011;25(12):1369-1380. doi:10.1111/j.1468-3083.2011.04278.x. PubMed

  • Kukla-Bartoszek M, Pośpiech E, Spólnicka M, et al. Investigating the impact of age-depended hair colour darkening during childhood on DNA-based hair colour prediction with the HIrisPlex system. Forensic Science International: Genetics. 2018;36:26-33. doi:10.1016/j.fsigen.2018.06.007. ScienceDirect

  • Modern Salon. Colorists elevate their talents at the Energizing Summit LA. 2014. modernsalon.com

  • Patch (Oak Forest, IL). Internationally regarded colorist comes to Chicagoland. 2015. patch.com

  • Peles DN, Hong L, Hu DN, Ito S, Nemanich RJ, Simon JD. Human iridal stroma melanosomes of varying pheomelanin contents possess a common eumelanic outer surface. Journal of Physical Chemistry B. 2009;113. doi:10.1021/jp904138n. Abstract

  • Peshek D, Semmaknejad N, Hoffman D, Foley P. Preliminary evidence that the limbal ring influences facial attractiveness. Evolutionary Psychology. 2011;9(2):137-146. doi:10.1177/147470491100900201. PubMed

  • Prota G, Hu DN, Vincensi MR, McCormick SA, Napolitano A. Characterization of melanins in human irides and cultured uveal melanocytes from eyes of different colors. Experimental Eye Research. 1998;67(3):293-299. doi:10.1006/exer.1998.0518. Record

  • Quicksilver Hair. The ultimate guide to hair porosity: does it really matter? quicksilverhair.com

  • Rodriguez M. Eye color and hair coloring. martinrodriguez.com

  • Shyu BP, Wyatt HJ. Appearance of the human eye: optical contributions to the "limbal ring." Optometry and Vision Science. 2009;86(9):E1069-E1077. doi:10.1097/OPX.0b013e3181b4f010. PubMed

  • Sulem P, Gudbjartsson DF, Stacey SN, et al. Genetic determinants of hair, eye and skin pigmentation in Europeans. Nature Genetics. 2007;39(12):1443-1452. doi:10.1038/ng.2007.13. Abstract

  • The Hair Society. Mags Kavanaugh: pioneering educator and innovator in the beauty industry. thehairsociety.org

  • Wella Professionals. Your guide to Wella's hair color charts. Wella blog, 2025. blog.wella.com

  • Wolfram LJ, Albrecht L. Chemical- and photo-bleaching of brown and red hair. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists. 1987;38(3):179-191. SCC library

Jessee Skittrall-Lemons

Jessee Skittrall-Lemons

Jessee Skittrall-Lemons brings a deep, multi-generational connection to the hairdressing industry, with six generations of hairdressers in the family and three decades of professional experience. Based in Washington State, Jessee continues to work behind the chair while also leading education and technical development that supports working professionals across the industry. Known for progressive cutting, thoughtful consultation strategy, and creative yet practical haircolor work, Jessee has worked internationally onstage and presented to global audiences. Jessee has also trained alongside and learned from respected industry leaders including Sam Brocato, Mary Brunetti, Ruth Roche, Vivienne Mackinder, Oscar and Wendy Bond, Scott Cole & Linda Yodice, and David Kinigson. Career highlights include serving on the Kadus Professional/Brocato Design Team and leading the Pacific Northwest Kadus Professional Education Team. Jessee holds certifications through both the American Board of Certified Haircolorists and the International Board of Certified Haircolorists, and currently serves as Technical Coach for KIN North America. Jessee has been a featured presenter at the ABCH Summit every year since its inception, presenting to sold-out audiences and contributing to the Summit’s reputation for advanced, practical education. Jessee also serves as Executive Director of the Board of Certified Haircolorists and is the founder of the Atarashii Apprentice Program, a federally registered apprenticeship pathway expanding access to licensure in cosmetology, barbering, esthetics, manicuring, and hair design. At the heart of Jessee’s work is a commitment to raising the standard of professional haircolor while widening access to legitimate, supported career pathways. Whether on the salon floor or on an education stage, Jessee is known for meeting professionals where they are, teaching with clarity, and championing growth that is both inspiring and achievable. Atarashii.org

LinkedIn logo icon
Back to Blog
Comments
Be the first to comment