Manufacturer Let Down

When Your Manufacturer Lets You Down: Why I’m Switching My Alkaline Demi (Again)

July 01, 2026•5 min read

When Your Manufacturer Lets You Down: Why I’m Switching My Alkaline Demi (Again)

I recently made a switch in my color lines. Overall, I was excited….new tools, new formulations, new possibilities! After months of testing, I landed on three different manufacturers for my three different lines, my permanent, alkaline demi (deposit only), and acidic demi (deposit only). I’ve been very happy so far with my choices, except my alkaline demi. It has been giving me absolute fits.

And that’s a problem, because this isn’t some fringe product I use once in a while. This is a daily driver. I use an alkaline demi on almost every client, whether I’m creating opaque lowlights, or using as a base, most of the time with the intention of covering gray when I don’t need lift.

This category has to be reliable. That’s a Non-negotiable.

As I started working more deeply with this new line, I noticed a consistent problem. Any time I used the naturals in levels 7, 8, or 9, the result was purple, dark, and completely wrong for what a natural should be doing. The naturals weren’t “cool,” nor “balanced.” They were purple.

At first, I assumed it was user error, because let’s be honest, that’s where we all start. I tried to correct it every way I could within the system. But the tones in the line had me limited. The only things I could mix with the naturals at levels 8+ were gold, which pushed the color into light red territory or a GB (gold blue), which landed me in a muddy purple slate.

Neither option got me where I needed to go. I wasn’t asking for magic…I just want a beautiful natural…not too warm, not to cool.

So, I did what we do when something doesn’t add up, I started swatching everything.

Same results. Over and over again.

Once I reached the point where I could confidently say, this is not a winning battle, I reached out to my sales rep, a fantastic guy who does a great job at shamelessly reading me the back of the box when I have a question. It’s his sweet way of saying that he has no idea. So he connected me with one of the brand’s “top educators.”

I explained everything clearly to this person, the consistent purple results happening on multiple clients as well as on controlled swatches.

The response?

If you’re seeing purple, your client should purchase our detox product. Their hair is probably full of metals.

I was furious.

Not because I’m anti-detox. Not because metals aren’t real.
But because this explanation ignored every piece of information I had just given.

Swatches don’t have metals.
Consistency across swatches points to formulation, not hair history.

Enter “Professor Silver Fox”....that same day, I had a client in my chair I lovingly call Professor Silver Fox. He’s a chemistry professor at the local college, has a full head of white hair, and is an absolute master of the ten-minute Midwestern goodbye. He’s chatty, brilliant, and always loves to answer any question that starts with “why”.

When I explained what I was seeing, he said something that immediately made sense:

“That sounds like an issue with the precursors in the color molecules. When those are off, you can get unintended tonal expression.”

I took that information to one of my most trusted industry experts, Jessee Skittrall, who confirmed that this was very likely what I was dealing with.

And this is the problem, the part that actually bothers me…

The person I was told to trust for answers from the manufacturer didn’t tell the truth.
To their benefit, maybe they didn’t know the answer, but instead of saying “I don’t know”, I was handed a lie that conveniently led to another purchase from the same company.

And that feels less like education… and more like manipulation.

How am I supposed to partner with a brand that won’t be honest with me?
Why is a lie better than transparency?
And why is the solution always to buy more?

So here's my decision, I’ve made up my mind.

I’ll be switching out my alkaline demi, again.

Not because I enjoy changing lines. We all know the ridiculous amount of work that goes into transferring out our color lines.
Not because I’m chasing trends.
But because I refuse to compromise my work, or my integrity, on a product that doesn’t perform as promised and a system that won’t tell the truth when something is wrong.

If you’ve been fighting a formula that should work but doesn’t…
If your swatches are telling a different story than your educator…
Trust your eyes. Trust your education. And don’t let anyone gaslight you into thinking it’s something you’re doing wrong when the chemistry doesn’t add up.

We deserve better tools, and better partners.

Sidebar: What Are Color Precursors—and Why They Matter

In oxidative haircolor (including alkaline demis), precursors are the small, colorless molecules that live inside the tube. On their own, they don’t look like much. But once they’re mixed with developer and exposed to oxygen, they oxidize, link together, and become the color molecules we actually see in the hair.

Think of precursors as the ingredients, not the finished dish.

Here’s why that matters:

  • Naturals are built on a balance of precursors.
    A true natural at levels 7–9 requires a very specific ratio of warm and cool precursors to land neutral. If that balance is off—even slightly—the color will lean.

  • Too much violet/blue precursor = unintended purple.
    If a formula contains an overabundance of cool precursors (often used to control warmth at lighter levels), the result can be a dense, dark, purple cast—even when no violet is intentionally added.

  • This shows up on swatches, not just clients.
    Metals, porosity, and environmental factors don’t affect clean swatches. When the same tone appears on swatches and on heads, that’s a formulation issue—not a hair issue.

  • Mixing within the line can’t always fix it.
    If the only modifiers available are gold (warm/red) or gold-blue (cool/violet-leaning), you’re forced into overcorrection. You’re no longer fine-tuning—you’re fighting the base chemistry.

  • This is why it feels “dark.”
    Overloaded precursors don’t just shift tone; they increase visual density. The color absorbs more light, reads heavier, and collapses depth—especially problematic in levels 7, 8, and 9.

The takeaway:
When a “natural” consistently goes purple across multiple heads and swatches, the issue isn’t detox, metals, or application. It’s the precursor balance in the formulation.

And no amount of education—or additional purchases—can correct chemistry that’s wrong at the source.

Marta Robinson

Marta Robinson

Marta Robinson is the Certification Development and Education Liaison for the Board of Certified Haircolorists and has been a Board Certified Haircolorist since 2011. She has 22 years of experience behind the chair and for the past 10 years has owned a commission salon in Indiana, demonstrating a long-standing commitment to advancing education, professionalism, and technical excellence in the haircolor industry. A lifelong learner and passionate educator, Marta has worked within the education network for both Beth Minardi Signature and Joico. She played a pivotal role in the passage of Apprenticeship legislation in Indiana in 2023, creating new pathways for aspiring professionals to pursue licensure through the state’s Apprentice-to-License program. Marta is a certified Great Lengths Extensionist and has honed her precision cutting skills at the Vidal Sassoon Academy. Her career education has spanned from California to New York, creating a blend of technical mastery, creative artistry, and a dedication to strengthening the professional development of stylists nationwide. Through her leadership with BCH and her ongoing mentorship within her local community, Marta continues to shape the next generation of hair professionals, ensuring the industry thrives on knowledge, integrity, and technical excellence.

Back to Blog
Comments
Be the first to comment